Vaseline vs Aquaphor: Which Is the Best for Dry Skin?
When comparing Vaseline and Aquaphor, both serve to prevent water loss from the skin, but their specific properties make one more effective for dry skin. So, which one is truly better?
Let’s dive into the details to help you decide the best option for your skincare needs.
Understanding Vaseline and Aquaphor
A quick fix for chapped lips or a dry patch of skin often involves reaching for either Aquaphor or Vaseline. While both are popular, they function slightly differently when it comes to dealing with irritated and flaky skin.
Dermatologists are clear on which one takes the lead in providing real relief for dry skin—let’s explore why.
Vaseline: A Skin Sealant but Not a True Moisturizer
Vaseline, a household name for petroleum jelly, works as an occlusive agent.
This means that it forms a barrier over the skin to lock in moisture, which is essential for keeping your skin soft and smooth. However, it doesn’t provide true hydration.
Why Vaseline Is an Occlusive
As dermatologist Dr. Ava Shamban explains, Vaseline prevents water loss from the skin but doesn’t hydrate it. “It’s a misstatement to call Vaseline a hydrator or a true moisturizer,” she says.
What it does is form a protective barrier to boost moisture levels and keep the skin supple, but it lacks the ability to pull moisture into the skin, unlike other products.
While Vaseline is excellent for protecting the skin, it’s not designed to add moisture back. It’s best used as a sealant after applying other hydrating products.
Aquaphor: The Triple Threat for Dry Skin
Like Vaseline, Aquaphor also contains petrolatum, but it has an added benefit—humectants and emollients—that make it more versatile for treating dry skin.
According to dermatologists, Aquaphor offers a blend of ingredients that make it a go-to solution for people dealing with severely dry or sensitive skin.
Humectants in Aquaphor: Why They Matter
Humectants, such as glycerin and panthenol, are ingredients that attract water from the air into the skin, actively hydrating it.
Dr. Loretta Ciraldo, a Miami-based dermatologist, frequently recommends Aquaphor to her patients, especially those dealing with post-surgery or post-procedure dryness. “Aquaphor is my go-to for post-op recovery because of its ability to soothe and heal dry, irritated skin,” says Dr. Ciraldo.
Emollients in Aquaphor: The Skin Softening Agent
Aquaphor also contains emollients like lanolin and mineral oil. These are lighter, oil-based ingredients that soften the skin.
These emollients work alongside humectants and occlusives to provide triple-action relief by drawing moisture into the skin, sealing it in, and softening rough patches. Aquaphor’s ability to both hydrate and protect makes it a standout in skincare routines.
Vaseline or Aquaphor: Which Is Better?
So, what’s the final verdict? Aquaphor comes out ahead as the better choice for dry skin. While Vaseline offers excellent protection by creating a barrier on the skin, it lacks the hydration that Aquaphor provides.
The added humectants and emollients in Aquaphor mean it does more than just protect—it actively works to heal dry skin by pulling in moisture and keeping the skin soft and hydrated.
That said, Vaseline can still be a helpful product for those who need a simple barrier, especially when applied after a moisturizer to lock in hydration. For long-term dry skin care, though, Aquaphor offers a more comprehensive solution.
Best Uses for Vaseline
- Healing Cuts and Burns: Vaseline can create a barrier that protects wounds from air and bacteria, helping cuts and burns heal faster.
- Preventing Chafing: By applying a small amount of Vaseline to areas prone to chafing, you can reduce friction and protect your skin from irritation.
- Protecting Lips: Vaseline can help lock moisture into your lips, preventing them from drying out in harsh weather.
Best Uses for Aquaphor
- Treating Eczema: Thanks to its hydrating and soothing properties, Aquaphor is a popular choice for treating eczema flare-ups.
- Post-Procedure Skin Care: As dermatologists recommend, Aquaphor is excellent for healing skin after procedures like chemical peels or laser treatments.
- Daily Moisturization: Aquaphor can be used as a daily moisturizer for dry skin, especially during colder months when skin tends to lose more moisture.
Key Differences Between Vaseline and Aquaphor
- Occlusive vs. Humectant: Vaseline works purely as an occlusive, meaning it seals in moisture but doesn’t hydrate. Aquaphor, on the other hand, contains humectants that attract water to the skin and emollients that soften it.
- Ingredients: While both contain petrolatum, Aquaphor also contains glycerin, panthenol, lanolin, and mineral oil—all of which contribute to its superior moisturizing abilities.
- Best for Sensitive Skin: Both are suitable for sensitive skin, but Aquaphor’s additional ingredients make it the better choice for extremely dry, flaky, or irritated skin.
Final Thoughts
In the battle between Vaseline and Aquaphor, Aquaphor is the more versatile and effective solution for most dry skin conditions.
While Vaseline has its merits, particularly as a protective barrier, it doesn’t provide the same level of hydration or healing power as Aquaphor.
For those struggling with dry, irritated skin, Aquaphor is the best option for both everyday use and more intensive treatment.
FAQs about Vaseline and Aquaphor
What is the main difference between Vaseline and Aquaphor?
Vaseline is primarily an occlusive that seals in moisture, while Aquaphor also contains humectants and emollients, making it a better moisturizer.
Can you use Vaseline or Aquaphor on your face?
Yes, both Vaseline and Aquaphor are safe to use on your face. However, Aquaphor may be more beneficial due to its added moisturizing ingredients.
Is Aquaphor better for healing cuts than Vaseline?
Aquaphor’s healing properties, thanks to its humectants and emollients, make it more effective for healing cuts and dry skin compared to Vaseline.
Does Vaseline clog pores?
Vaseline is non-comedogenic, meaning it won’t clog your pores. However, it’s best used as a top layer over other products, not as a standalone moisturizer.
Which is better for dry hands—Vaseline or Aquaphor?
Aquaphor is the better choice for dry hands as it hydrates and protects. Vaseline can lock in moisture but doesn’t actively hydrate the skin.
Reference Links:
